I've got mixed feelings about our country's reaction to the news of Osama Bin Laden's death - and I was fortunate to be tucked safely away in Providence on 9/11 nor did I lose anyone on that day. So I can't even compare to those who've lost loved ones either to terrorism/the war on terrorism or have suffered PTSD and other ramifications of physical and emotional trauma.
Vindication? Joy? Disgust? Satisfaction? Relief may be the best way to describe the mood of the night. But I can't help feel that the historic moment was somewhat sensationalized by social media and I appreciate the irony of my expressing my views via the same avenues...
I, like many Americans and other citizens of the world went to bed later than planned last night due to the breaking news (and am now guzzling coffee as a consequence - coffee vendors should be seeing increased revenue today). While it was inspiring to hear Obama's words confirming Osama's death (say that 5 times fast without swapping the names), the celebratory scenes at the White House gates felt almost... voyeuristic? Granted, most of them were college students, and let's be honest, most of us given an opportunity to take a break from finals and be a part of history would have seized the opportunity as well. However, being a lipreader, I was surprised to see some of the things that were said that the microphones couldn't pick up. One female student was saying, "We killed him! We killed him!" And that didn't quite resonate with me. As I ponder, I have to remind myself that these college students were 7 to 12 years old when 9/11 occurred so this generation has a different notion of what being an American means.
However, if this celebration filmed was at a US base and showing soldiers celebrating in the same manner, would my reaction have been different? Probably - but then again, the soldiers are over there making the ultimate sacrifice. Shouldn't they deserve to celebrate and blow off some steam? Maybe so. But ten years ago, Americans were disgusted to see others rejoicing at the events of 9/11 - should it be different now that we're on the other side of the mirror? I personally think not, let us take the higher road and be respectful.
But I digress, also on the news last night was a call from a woman who'd lost her husband on 9/11. When asked if she now felt closure, she replied beautifully. (Paraphrasing) "No, I wouldn't say this brings closure, it doesn't change the loss or bring my husband and the others who've died since back. But it is a new chapter, the page is turning."
And a new chapter it is, indeed. The leader of a radical movement has been dealt with - but he was just one of many and for some he represented good things so those are experiencing a sense of loss, frustration and even revenge. Nothing in this world is objective - we all learned about biased media and propaganda when in high school (hopefully) and many of our brothers and sisters in the Middle East may not have been exposed to what we consider to be the objective truth so they should not necessarily be castigated for their beliefs. Not to mention that the behavior shown by many on last night's media did not portray Americans favorably to our enemies and may have added fuel to the fire.
Yes - I get it, Bin Laden was a man of evil principles and violated human rights left and right. Did he deserve what was coming to him - that's one way of putting it. But instead of rejoicing at the fact of death - shouldn't we redirect our emotions to a sense of gratitude to those who've made the true sacrifices and lend our support to those who suffered, both American as well as the civilians of Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan? Not to mention that the nature of some of these celebrations, virtual and live, may even lend to further backlash from Al Qaeda.
Blame it on my Catholic upbringing that I have a hard time with the idea of rejoicing in the death and misery of others. Although there are some darn good sartorial cracks floating around on Twitter that had more juice than the guy w/the comb over and managed to elicit a chuckle or two from me, I still feel that this should be more of a solemn rather than a celebratory event. It's a morale booster - that's for sure, but as many others have expressed, how much does it really change?
But one must keep the focus on the big picture. And I personally think Obama did a beautiful job of doing just that in his speech last night and reminding us that we need to keep a sense of national unity. How do we go forward from here? We keep on being safe and smart - Osama Bin Laden's death was but one act in an ongoing war. Call me cautiously optimistic, but we are not out of the red zone yet, and in fact, risks levels are elevated with potential retaliation and threats.
How to wrap up my brain ramblings? Well, with mixed feelings - you can't. Just please keep in mind that there is nothing objective and to every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction. Let us do what little we can to dispel the myths of ignorant Americans and keep the momentum moving towards peace, one day.
(Now, can we get May 1st to finally be declared a Federal Holiday? It IS the International Workers' Day after all...)
Vindication? Joy? Disgust? Satisfaction? Relief may be the best way to describe the mood of the night. But I can't help feel that the historic moment was somewhat sensationalized by social media and I appreciate the irony of my expressing my views via the same avenues...
I, like many Americans and other citizens of the world went to bed later than planned last night due to the breaking news (and am now guzzling coffee as a consequence - coffee vendors should be seeing increased revenue today). While it was inspiring to hear Obama's words confirming Osama's death (say that 5 times fast without swapping the names), the celebratory scenes at the White House gates felt almost... voyeuristic? Granted, most of them were college students, and let's be honest, most of us given an opportunity to take a break from finals and be a part of history would have seized the opportunity as well. However, being a lipreader, I was surprised to see some of the things that were said that the microphones couldn't pick up. One female student was saying, "We killed him! We killed him!" And that didn't quite resonate with me. As I ponder, I have to remind myself that these college students were 7 to 12 years old when 9/11 occurred so this generation has a different notion of what being an American means.
However, if this celebration filmed was at a US base and showing soldiers celebrating in the same manner, would my reaction have been different? Probably - but then again, the soldiers are over there making the ultimate sacrifice. Shouldn't they deserve to celebrate and blow off some steam? Maybe so. But ten years ago, Americans were disgusted to see others rejoicing at the events of 9/11 - should it be different now that we're on the other side of the mirror? I personally think not, let us take the higher road and be respectful.
But I digress, also on the news last night was a call from a woman who'd lost her husband on 9/11. When asked if she now felt closure, she replied beautifully. (Paraphrasing) "No, I wouldn't say this brings closure, it doesn't change the loss or bring my husband and the others who've died since back. But it is a new chapter, the page is turning."
And a new chapter it is, indeed. The leader of a radical movement has been dealt with - but he was just one of many and for some he represented good things so those are experiencing a sense of loss, frustration and even revenge. Nothing in this world is objective - we all learned about biased media and propaganda when in high school (hopefully) and many of our brothers and sisters in the Middle East may not have been exposed to what we consider to be the objective truth so they should not necessarily be castigated for their beliefs. Not to mention that the behavior shown by many on last night's media did not portray Americans favorably to our enemies and may have added fuel to the fire.
Yes - I get it, Bin Laden was a man of evil principles and violated human rights left and right. Did he deserve what was coming to him - that's one way of putting it. But instead of rejoicing at the fact of death - shouldn't we redirect our emotions to a sense of gratitude to those who've made the true sacrifices and lend our support to those who suffered, both American as well as the civilians of Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan? Not to mention that the nature of some of these celebrations, virtual and live, may even lend to further backlash from Al Qaeda.
Blame it on my Catholic upbringing that I have a hard time with the idea of rejoicing in the death and misery of others. Although there are some darn good sartorial cracks floating around on Twitter that had more juice than the guy w/the comb over and managed to elicit a chuckle or two from me, I still feel that this should be more of a solemn rather than a celebratory event. It's a morale booster - that's for sure, but as many others have expressed, how much does it really change?
But one must keep the focus on the big picture. And I personally think Obama did a beautiful job of doing just that in his speech last night and reminding us that we need to keep a sense of national unity. How do we go forward from here? We keep on being safe and smart - Osama Bin Laden's death was but one act in an ongoing war. Call me cautiously optimistic, but we are not out of the red zone yet, and in fact, risks levels are elevated with potential retaliation and threats.
How to wrap up my brain ramblings? Well, with mixed feelings - you can't. Just please keep in mind that there is nothing objective and to every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction. Let us do what little we can to dispel the myths of ignorant Americans and keep the momentum moving towards peace, one day.
(Now, can we get May 1st to finally be declared a Federal Holiday? It IS the International Workers' Day after all...)
No comments:
Post a Comment